Lyme-Old Lyme HS Senior Sheehan Smashes 49-Year-Old Shot Put School Record

On Saturday, Lyme-Old Lyme High School Senior Dylan Sheehan broke the school shot put record , which had stood for a remarkable 49 years. All photos by A. Daquila.

OLD LYME — UPDATED 5/16 with previous record holder’s first name — many thanks to John Ressler of Old Lyme for notifying us of it and letting us know that he was there 49 years ago when the previous record was set! On May 6, Lyme-Old Lyme High School (LOLHS) Senior Dylan Sheehan smashed a 49-year-old shot put school record at the ‘Shot Put Saturday’ Invitational in Middletown

According to LOLHS history teacher Aron Daquila, who manages the track and field program at the school, “The prior record was set in 1974 by P. [Paul] Marshall with a very impressive distance of 51 ft. 4 ins.”  

Dylan Sheehan in action during ‘Shotput Saturday’ at the Middletown Invitational contest.

Sheehan threw 54 ft. 3 ins. on his third attempt, thereby breaking the previous record convincingly. Asked by LymeLine today how he felt about breaking a record that had been on the books for 49 years, Sheehan responded by email, “It felt great to break the school record, and it was really special as I’ve been in a slump since indoor ended.”

He added, “I didn’t expect this personal record at all, but after trying a big technical change at the meet, the results came through,” noting humbly, “While setting a new record was very nice, records are meant to be broken, and my records will surely fall when someone works harder than I did.” 

This photo shows Dylan Sheehan seconds after throwing what became his record-breaking shot put.

Not only did Sheehan finish second overall in the shot put contest, but he also came away with a first place finish in the discus.  

We also connected with Sheehan’s coach Nick Bradley, and asked him how it felt to have worked with the athlete, who broke such a long-standing record.

Bradley replied by email, “It was incredible to witness Dylan break this record. Dylan is as hard a worker as they come. He is consistently going above and beyond what is asked of him at practice, so as a coach, there is nothing better than seeing the hard work and dedication of one of your athletes pay off.”

Bradley elaborated, saying, “It has been great coaching Dylan for the last two seasons. Not only does he work hard to achieve his goals but he is always helping his teammates to achieve theirs as well. As a coach you couldn’t ask for more out of an athlete. He will be missed next season.”

Is Sheehan going to rest on his laurels now? Definitely not, according to Bradley, who commented, “Dylan’s next goals are to challenge for state titles in shot put, discus and hammer. And in doing so, he is also looking break the schools discus record [of 165 ft.] set by Jared Stanland in 2014, before he (Dylan) heads off to Bates in the fall.

Editor’s Note: Congratulations and good luck, Dylan, from all of us at LymeLine.com! And many thanks to John Ressler for giving us the first name of the previous record-holder, Paul Marshall, who was member of the LOLHS Class of 1974. Ressler noted he remembers well the day Marshall achieved the record.

Author

Olwen Logan grew up in a family of London educators but was inspired by her great grandfather, influential Daily Chronicle newspaper editor Alfred Ewen Fletcher, to pursue journalism. She built a successful career in efficiency analysis and senior audit management before launching her own PR-focused consultancy. After moving to the U.S. in 1990 and settling in Old Lyme in 1994, she became a staff writer for the now-closed Main Street News and later joined Jack Turner’s fledgling LymeLine.com, discovering the career she had always wanted—albeit in an unexpected digital form. Even after relocating to Maryland, she continued covering Lyme and Old Lyme with the same dedication, earning national recognition as a LION Publishers award finalist in 2020. After more than two decades of service, Olwen stepped away in November 2025, donating LymeLine.com to the newly formed nonprofit LymeLine Inc. and expressing her excitement for its continued growth and mission.