Lyme ZBA to Decide Koch Case on Existing Record Next Month

The board postponed its court-ordered review of the Avenue B application until next month, when it will decide without a public hearing or new evidence.

Lyme Town Hall. Credit: James Meehan/LymeLine.

LYME, CT – The Zoning Board of Appeals, ordered by a state Superior Court judge to reconsider a property owner’s application for variances to build a house on Avenue B, postponed discussion and possible action Thursday because all five members were not present.

Chairman Fred Harger said the board will reconvene Dec. 17, with board Attorney Michael Carey of Suisman Shapiro specifying there will be no public hearing or consideration of additional evidence.

The case stems from the board’s denial in 2021 and 2025 of the application from former First Selectman William T. Koch Jr. to construct a house on a 10,193-square-foot lot in a zone where the buildable minimum is 15,000 square feet. 

Koch, an attorney, represented himself in appealing the denials to the state Superior Court in January. 

Judge Kevin C. Shea on Oct. 7 ruled that the board “abused its discretion and acted without substantial evidence” in denying the variances. Shea sustained Koch’s appeal and sent the application back to the board “to make a ruling on the merits of the application.” 

The board is responsible for evaluating applications against local zoning regulations to decide if variances are justified. 

Carey, who sat with Zoning Enforcement Officer Lannie Mossberg and ZBA members at the table in the Town Hall meeting room, rebuffed attempts by Koch to enter a statement on the record. Carey said those at the table should be the only ones involved in the discussion on the application. 

“Mr. Koch, we’re taking the position that we are here to do what the court directed the board to do when it ruled in your favor on the appeal, and that was to vote on the merits,” he said. “And in my view, there is going to be no public hearing.”

Carey said he was aware of the points Koch wanted to raise and would bring them to the board when it begins its deliberations at the next meeting.

Author

Elizabeth started her journalism career in 2013 with the launch of The Salem Connect, a community news site inspired by digital trailblazers like Olwen Logan. Elizabeth’s earliest reporting included two major fires — one at a package store and another at a log cabin where she captured, on video, a state trooper fatally shooting the unarmed homeowner and suspected arsonist. The experiences gave her a crash course in public record searches, courthouse procedures and the Freedom of Information Act. She went on to report for The Bulletin, CT News Junkie, The Rivereast, and The Day, where she covered the Lymes and helped launch the Housing Solutions Lab on affordable housing. Her work has earned numerous awards from the Connecticut Society of Professional Journalists and the New England Newspaper & Press Association. Now, after more than a decade in digital, weekly, and daily journalism, she’s grateful to return to the place where it all started: an online news site dedicated to one small corner of Connecticut.

Comments (0)

There are no comments on this article.

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated. Please review our Commenting Policy before posting.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.