Court Orders Lyme ZBA to Rule on Avenue B House Proposal
A state Superior Court judge ruled the Zoning Board of Appeals lacked evidence to deny William T. Koch Jr.’s proposal. The board will reconsider the application Thursday.

LYME, CT – New London Superior Court has decided in favor of a Lyme resident and property owner who wants to build a single-family house on Avenue B and wants the Zoning Board of Appeals to evaluate his application based on the facts and evidence.
Attorney William T. Koch Jr. said the board acted unfairly and illegally in 2021 and 2025 denials of the application. He purchased the lot in 2019 under Koch Northeast LLC and represented the LLC in the court case against the ZBA.
Koch, who served as Lyme’s first selectman from 2001 to 2007, said the board has not given a reason for denying the application.
“I do not think that legally that they have a legal reason to deny it,” Koch said in a phone call last week. “In 2021 they denied it for no reason and there was no reason in 2025.”
In an Oct. 7 decision, the court sided with Koch.
Judge Kevin C. Shea ruled that the board “abused its discretion and acted without substantial evidence” when it denied the application without considering its merits. The judge sustained Koch’s appeal and remanded the application to the ZBA for a decision on its merits.
Zoning Enforcement Officer Lannie Mossberg, who said she could not comment on the matter “as it’s active and ongoing,” noted Koch’s application will be on the ZBA’s agenda on Thursday, Nov. 19 for possible action.
Per court documents and meeting minutes, Koch asked for waivers of the 15,000-square-foot minimum buildable area to construct a house on the 10,193-square-foot lot.
In February 2021, then-Zoning Enforcement Officer Ross Byrne refused to give Koch a building permit despite the applicant’s assertion that the parcel is a legal, nonconforming lot that conforms to the neighborhood.
Mossberg said Byrne, who is now her part-time assistant, will not comment.
After Byrne’s rejection, Koch went before the ZBA.
In April 2021, the board unanimously approved a motion to deny the variances as presented.
That same year, Koch filed and ultimately withdrew an appeal with the Superior Court.
In late 2024, he filed a second application with the ZBA.
In January 2025, the ZBA concluded the second application was the same as the first and opted not to consider it separately.
Koch said the 1,736-square-foot house he wants to build would fit in with the rest of the homes in the neighborhood and he hopes to sell it to “a nice young family” that wants to live in Lyme. He said it would be one of the more affordable homes in town.
Koch envisions the family that buys the home would be teachers, firefighters or other working-class individuals.
Koch this week said if the ZBA denies the application again, he’ll appeal to the Superior Court.
If he loses in Superior Court, he will consider filing a new application to build a deed-restricted affordable home.
The state’s affordable housing law, known as 8-30g, makes it easier for developers to sue zoning commissions when proposals that would help address the state’s housing shortage are denied.
The law affects any municipality where less than 10% of the housing stock meets the state’s definition of affordable. Qualifying homes must carry a 40-year deed restriction to ensure the property remains accessible to lower-income households. According to the state Department of Housing’s most recent annual accounting, 0.90% of Lyme’s housing stock is affordable.
“In such a case, I believe the ZBA has the legal burden of proving it should be denied,” he said.
He said if the board refuses to allow him to build on the lot, it will be the same as the government taking it because he can’t do anything with it.
“It’s like confiscation,” he said.
He argued the same thing in his appeal.
While he believes some neighbors may be on his side and afraid to go against the grain, Koch said neighbors who spoke at public hearings were against him building the house despite the fact that it “totally fits in with the neighborhood.”
Neighbor’s Concerns
According to the minutes from the November 2024 public hearing, Attorney Larry Shipman represented neighbors Paul and Jackie Noniewicz. He argued the smaller setbacks Koch was requesting and the location of the garage would be detrimental to neighbors.
Shipman also said the lot is similar to others in the neighborhood that have been used to gain access to Rogers Lake, rather than for building, and that the assessed value of the property reflects this use.
According to Assessor Jen Thomas, the property is assessed at $4,600.
Shipman said Koch’s arguments were based on economic considerations and did not represent a unique physical characteristic of the property that would count as a “hardship” that would qualify him for a variance.
Koch later said he was not claiming economic hardship and believes the size of the lot is a physical characteristic that qualifies him for a variance.
Neighbor Cheryl Sorenson expressed concern for a brook near the lot that has a history of flooding. She added that granting a variance could set a precedent for similarly sized lots in the neighborhood.
Koch said the ZBA has discretion when considering applications and has acted in favor of property owners in the past.
He said the town has spent more than $27,000 fighting him in court and has no reason to prevent him from building the house.
“All I’m looking for is a fair hearing where they decide the case on its merits,” he said. “They should pass it. It should pass. If they act legally and not arbitrarily and follow their legal precedents in Lyme, they should pass it.”
Seeking Rutigliano’s Return
On Monday, the Board of Selectpeople declined to reappoint former ZBA alternate member Jeanne Rutigliano after Koch asked the officials to allow her to return to the board for one night.
Rutigliano sat on all the hearings and was ready to vote on the merits of the application in 2025, Koch told selectpeople. Because the ZBA decided not to consider the application, she was unable to vote on it.
“After that meeting, she resigned from the board,” he said. “She’s willing to go back on to vote.”
Koch argued that the town had abused its discretion and, had it not done so, the board would have voted in January 2025. He said all members still sit on the board except Rutigliano and requested that she be allowed to return for one night to vote on the application.
Koch said temporarily reappointing Rutigliano is the only way to “put things back” to the way they were before the commission denied the application.
There is no vacancy on the board for a full, voting member. One alternate position is open. An alternate member may be called in to vote only when a regular board member is absent.
Selectman Tom St. Louis said it’s not the selectmen’s place to “make a one-time assignment” to the ZBA in order to execute a review of Koch’s application.
“From my perspective, it’s overreach on the Board of Selectmen to override what a board in town, duly elected, is intending to do,” he told Koch. “And they are intending to hear your application on Thursday, with the board construct as-is.”
First Selectwoman Christy Zelek said Town Attorney Mike Carey, of Suisman Shapiro, told her he could find no legal grounds to reappoint Rutigliano.
Comments (0)
There are no comments on this article.